Skip to main content

Does Shylock Really Deserve It?

I have repeatedly discussed the impact that Shylock's character could have on a 21st century, post-Holocaust audience. And while I do think that many of his character traits are or could be seen as anti-Semitic, I really do believe that he deserves what he gets in the context of the play.

You see, if we are going by the logic that the characters in the play are subject to the real and historical implications of the time period, then Shylock has been prejudiced outside of his scuffles with Antonio, and I could see where his behavior comes from. However, many Jews could restrain themselves even in the face of undeniable horrific hate. Shylock is not a bad guy because he's a Jew: he's just a bad guy. He even makes a case for himself that Jews inherently are not so different from Christians. So yes, Shylock deserves it for being uncaring about his daughter and threatening to kill a man.

I personally believe that Elizabethan audiences would probably have thought it funny that a Jew loses and has many stereotypical qualities, and I think Shakespeare was probably trying to make the play appeal to an anti-Semitic audience. Whether he was actually anti-Semitic, I can't say for sure. However, my opinion still stands.

Comments

  1. Kim HarrisonFebruary 21, 2017 at 11:40 AM

    What do you think Shakespeare was getting at by forcing Shylock to convert to Christianity? He could have just let the court kill him off or take all of his money, but Antonio insists that he also convert. What is the point of this?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Use of Formulaic Language in the Odyssey

Because the Odyssey  was written circa. 800 B.C.E, it obviously wasn't meant to be read by a bunch of high-schoolers at a Montessori school in 2016 Houston, Texas. It, gathered from research by linguists, archaeologists, and historians, was almost certainly meant to be performed. I don't think anybody has mentioned that only the major or supporting characters in the Odyssey are given epithets (ie. "Owl-eyed Athena, godly Nestor, Red-haired Menelaus "), and there is quite a lot of supporting characters for a relatively short epic compared to the length of fantasy & epic literature today. Because of this, these epithets were not only used for rhythm and splendor when performing. In fact, some were likely put there to remind the audience members of characters that haven't been seen in a while. However, for the characters like Zeus, Poseidon, and Athena who appear often, the performance explanation seems to be the greatest. However, another possible reason is ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Sound Devices in "We Real Cool"

THE POOL PLAYERS. SEVEN AT THE GOLDEN SHOVEL. We real cool. We Left school. We Lurk late. We Strike straight. We Sing sin. We Thin gin. We Jazz June. We Die soon. We Real Cool" is a great piece of literature. It doesn't take more than fifteen seconds to read, and yet I found it to be one of the most interesting poems I have come across, not only for its surprisingly deep meaning, but also for it's enjoyable and catchy use of sound devices. Some uses of sound devices in the poem are obvious. For example, the two sentences in each stanza (not counting the use of enjambment with the word "we", which, by the way, is an interesting visual choice) produce a couplet, as they rhyme. However, looking deeper into the poem, we start to see more hidden devices, such as the consecutive rhyme "we thin gin" and the fact that on the first and second lines of the second and and the first line of the fourth stanza, al...
Post a Comment
Read more

How Were Frederick Douglass's Human Rights Violated?

A human right is any such right that is guaranteed to each and every human regardless of creed, class, color, race, gender, or sexuality upon birth. However, to say that because every human is guaranteed these rights that these rights are untouched is a falsity. Today, human rights are constantly violated every day, and it was no different in Douglass's time. In Chapter 10, on page 35 of the novel, Douglass describes how we was sent by his then-master, Mr. Covey, to gather a load of wood using a wooden cart and two oxen. Covey tells Douglass to hold on tight when the oxen begin running. In no fault of his own, Douglass is dragged at an immense speed by the oxen, who crash the cart into rocks and trees. When Mr. Covey learns of this, Douglass is then brutally whipped, even though he had no prior experience with oxen and this particular exercise. Beyond slavery itself violating an essential human right, Douglass describes the numerous times when he is beaten, occasionally to life-t...
Post a Comment
Read more